Five friends can each bring a Commander list and pay $38 apiece to get all five decks printed. Leave one card out of that PrintMTG order and the bill actually goes up. At PrintMTG, 499 cards cost $224.55. Add the last card and the whole order qualifies for the 38-cent rate, bringing the bill down to $190. When comparing budget proxy printing services, count your cards first. Then decide who’s going to spend an evening choosing artwork for them.
How Much Does It Cost to Print 500 MTG Proxies?
These prices cover 500 nonfoil cards going to one U.S. address, before tax, checked November 10, 2026. For MakePlayingCards (MPC), we priced a single 63 × 88 mm batch of up to 504 cards with standard finish and shrink-wrap. We divided its estimated shipped price by the 500 cards requested.
| Service | With standard U.S. shipping | Per card | Stock |
|---|---|---|---|
| PrintMTG | $190 shipped | 38¢ | Smooth black-core stock |
| Proxy Foundry | $190 shipped | 38¢ | UV-coated, die-cut cardstock |
| MakePlayingCards S30 | $153.84 estimated | 30.77¢ | Smooth blue-core stock |
| MakePlayingCards S33 | $171.84 estimated | 34.37¢ | Smooth black-core stock |
| Sideboarding | $200 shipped | 40¢ | Matte-laminated photo stock |
PrintMTG and Proxy Foundry Offer the Best Overall Value
For an order built from existing decklists, we rate PrintMTG and Proxy Foundry close on quality. Both let you paste card names and quantities, choose the set versions you want, and leave production to the printer. PrintMTG uses smooth black-core playing-card stock. Proxy Foundry specifies a UV coating and die-cut edges. At the same $190 price, we’d be happy handing either set of decks to the table.
They’re also good picks when the next game night is on the calendar. PrintMTG lists one to three business days for production and three to seven more for standard U.S. transit. Proxy Foundry says many U.S. orders arrive in five to nine business days total. Both say large orders can take longer. Starting with a finished decklist also saves the time you’d spend preparing and checking 500 individual images.
MakePlayingCards Gives You the Most Design Control
MakePlayingCards is the one we’d choose for an artist-designed cube. You can give every card its own front and back, lay out rules text in a frame you designed, and pick the stock and finish for the batch. A group bringing five different Commander lists can combine them in one 504-slot project. Set the order quantity to one. That quantity counts copies of the entire project.
The choice between S30 and S33 comes down to $18 across the batch, or $3.60 per player if five people split it evenly. Both have a smooth finish. S30 has a blue core and S33 has a black core. I’d order S30 for a new cube that will live in opaque sleeves. For a group that already plays with S33, I’d quote that stock first. With estimated standard U.S. shipping, that works out to about $34.37 per Commander deck, versus about $30.77 on S30.
A 504-slot order gives you four places left after the 500. For a Commander group, I’d ask which token people borrow most and use the slots for those. For a custom cube, they could hold four alternate versions of cards you’re still testing. MPC Autofill can arrange the images and transfer the project to MakePlayingCards. Use art you have permission to print and look over the final previews, especially the backs of double-faced cards.
What Does MakePlayingCards Charge for U.S. Shipping?
For one 504-card deck (63 × 88 mm), we checked MPC’s U.S. shipping estimator for S30 and S33 separately. Both returned $36.99 for standard, $49.90 for express, and $79.84 for priority express. Standard postage adds 7.4 cents per card across the 500 requested. Before tax or other checkout charges, that brings the $116.85 S30 print price to $153.84 and the $134.85 S33 print price to $171.84.
On S33, express shipping brings MPC to $184.75, just $5.25 below PrintMTG with standard shipping. Priority express brings MPC to $214.69. For a group splitting five decks, even standard shipping leaves just $3.63 per player between MPC S33 and PrintMTG. Saving that money is more compelling when choosing your own art is part of the fun.
Why We’d Skip Sideboarding for 500 Cards
Sideboarding is affordable at 40 cents a card, and it says most orders ship in one business day. Its cards use 200 gsm photo paper with matte lamination. For decks that see regular play, we rate the cardstock and finish of PrintMTG and Proxy Foundry substantially higher. A 500-card Sideboarding order comes to $200 shipped, so the group would pay $10 extra for the option we like least. We’d skip it at this quantity.
How to Split Five Commander Decks in One Order
Five complete Commander decks make exactly 500 cards, including their commanders. On PrintMTG, five separate 100-card orders come to $275 in cards before any postage. One 500-card order comes to $190 with standard U.S. shipping. Combining the lists saves $85 in printing alone, or $17 per player. Sideboarding’s printing subtotal stays at $200 either way. Combining the lists saves on shipping there.
How to Use 500 Cards for a Draft Cube
A 500-card print order can include both the draft pool and the extras that live in the cube box. For example, I’d consider 450 draftable cards, 30 tokens, and 20 cards to swap in later. An eight-player draft uses 360 cards when everyone opens three 15-card packs. With a 450-card pool, 90 sit out each session. Keep tokens, test cards, and your supply of basic lands separate when you make the packs.
There’s a price reason to plan those extras. On PrintMTG, printing just the 450-card pool costs $202.50. Adding 50 useful cards brings the total down to $190. A finished 360-card cube is a different decision. The same printer charges $162 for 360, so expanding to 500 costs another $28. I’d pay that for cards to try a few new draft archetypes. If I was happy with the list, I’d spend it on sleeves.
Questions About Bulk Proxy Orders
Can the 500 cards all be different?
Yes. MakePlayingCards allows individual fronts and backs within a deck. PrintMTG and Proxy Foundry let you build orders from card lists and set quantities. That works for a singleton cube with 500 distinct cards or for five decks that share staples.
What if our five lists leave out the basic lands?
Use the number of physical cards you still need. If you own 100 of the 500 cards, the remaining 400 cost $180 at PrintMTG. Filling the order back up to 500 would cost $10 more. If your friends have another 100 cards they want, that’s a good price for the extras. If they don’t, keep the $10.
Does the group get five separately packaged decks?
The MPC price above buys one shrink-wrapped project. Plan to sort it yourselves. The other comparisons also assume one combined order going to a single address. If separate packaging or delivery to five homes matters, get that price before dividing the bill.
Which Service Would I Use for 500 Cards?
For five finished Commander decks, we’d split a $190 PrintMTG or Proxy Foundry order and let everyone choose their favorite printings. For a custom cube with original artwork, we’d use MPC and put the four spare slots toward matching tokens. Sideboarding’s $200 price gives a bulk buyer little reason to compromise on the card quality we prefer.
References
- PrintMTG card pricing and shipping threshold
- PrintMTG production and U.S. shipping times
- Proxy Foundry 500-card price and printing specifications
- Sideboarding pricing, materials, and shipping
- MakePlayingCards custom game cards and stock configurator
- MakePlayingCards shipping cost estimator
- MakePlayingCards shipping information
- MPC Autofill project editor
- Wizards of the Coast Commander format rules
- Lucky Paper’s cube booster draft format